You would be surprised to know that the Salvadorians and Guatemalans are actually entering Mexico both legally and illegally. I served my mission on the Guatemalan border. There are quite a few places of refuge run by priests that aren't even touched by the govt. You would also notice the USA saying to Mexico not to cross illegally because you would be first priority for deportation. Even the Mex govt has put up signs NOT to cross illegally to the USA. So in all of that Trump is incorrect.Serragon wrote:If this is true then why doesn't the Mexican govt allow free flow of Guatemalans and El Salvadorans into Mexico for a better life? Don't they come from the same basic cultural background and understanding? Seems to be a tad bit of hypocrisy here...samizdat wrote:Except they can't. I noticed you ignored the hard working aspects of these immigrants that come across the border and that tend to be conservative religiously speaking (vast majority Catholic or Evangelical, a few Mormons mixed in there too). You also ignore the fact that many of those that DO cross in the manner that they do cross because they have NO other available options (no money, no local opprotunities, no assistance, etc). Getting a visa costs time and money, money which these people jumping or tunneling across do not have.Serragon wrote:The only thing clear for you is what you heard. I asked for you to post the quotes. Of the ones I have read, none of them say what you heard.samizdat wrote: He was pretty clear about what he said.
Everyone should be punished for their own transgression. Whoever said otherwise? The adjective illegal indicates something here...samizdat wrote: Do we punish everyone for the sins of a few? Do we break up families because some are illegal? Or do we try an approach where we are more humane, have them pay fines for entering illegally, and have them pay back taxes as well? I prefer the more humane option.
It is the illegal immigrant families who are breaking themselves up. When you decide to do something illegal, this is the risk you take. They can all go live in Mexico together as one happy family if they so choose. Why is it suddenly the US govt responsibility to make sure criminals are allowed to live together with their families in the place of the criminals choosing? Don't you hold people accountable for their own actions?
The Mexican culture comes from a rich influence of Spanish and prehispanic influences, cultures that DID have something to do with morals back in the day despite what we read in the history books. The Spanish killed some indigenous folks and intermarried with the others. The Aztec and Maya didn't die off. They just simply mixed with the Spanish.
And in that culture, you have the idea of the SPIRIT of the Law over the LETTER of the law. Taught by their white god Quetzalcoatl or Kukulkan (which John Taylor concluded to be Jesus Christ). One of those laws said if you stole something you were worthy to be punished with death. However the law stated that if you were poor, you could grab the corn that was alongside the road, up to four stalks inside. No one really judged if someone was poor or rich, but the first four stalks (out of dozens) were fair game.
If you are poor and you have a family to feed, are you going to give them a 100 peso (6 USD) salary a day, which is a typical wage for these people? Or are you going to seize an opprotunity to get a 7.50 or better USD wage which no American will do, and build your house in Mexico with what you get there? The American grows blue in the face saying that's illegal. The Mexican says, I'm just helping out my family. Both based on their cultures.
The American culture comes from a mixed up influence of several European cultures over time.
Mexico's immigration laws have become more liberal since Calderon. Peña Nieto hasnt changed too much either.
I will give u this however: you should have ID's to vote. Mexico requires them (special voter ID given by the natl electoral institute. No ID, no vote