Is Pleasure same as Joy?

For discussion of liberty, freedom, government and politics.
Juliet
captain of 1,000
Posts: 3701

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by Juliet »

larsenb wrote: November 16th, 2017, 11:42 am Though joy is pleasurable, I would say it goes beyond mere pleasure. Maybe some of you have already mentioned this, but I think you could say that joy does embody other powerful emotions/perceptions including the sense of gratitude and awe that I mentioned. I think it also induces a sense of having been connected with something very profound (awe?) and it reinvigorates your sense that life has deep meaning, which also brings a sense of responsibility in how your conduct and lead your life . . . almost a moral component to it.
Perhaps joy is Pleasure that has depth to it, it may have physical characteristics but the meaning stretches into the past, present, and future. Most favorite foods are associated with a past meaningful experience where love was felt. So, pleasure that triggers loving memories, spawns loving actions, and inspires a better future is attainable because of the spirituality it invokes.

Rand
captain of 1,000
Posts: 2472

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by Rand »

larsenb wrote: November 15th, 2017, 11:36 pm
Rand wrote: November 15th, 2017, 2:56 pm . . . . . . Pleasure is, although enjoyable, a state of physical perception that can be noble, but can be distorted by the adversary to further his purposes. . . . . . .
Notice how you say: "Pleasure is . . . enjoyable . . . " Notice the embedded 'joy' in enjoyable. You could also say: "Joy is pleasurable" . . . and if you disagree with that statement, are you then saying that joy is not pleasurable, is not pleasing??

Of course you are welcome to select how you want to use the word pleasure. Philosophers do this type of thing quite a bit, but they try to make it very clear how they are expanding or narrowing the meaning of a word or phrase beyond or as a subset of the conventional meaning, and that the usage they put forth is to be used only in the context of their philosophical system.
Good observation. I would contend that, even though the root of enjoyable, is joy, it does not carry all of the meaning nor connotations of joy. I do have broader beliefs about the word Joy, and you could call them philosophical in context. I am looking at the word Joy as the scriptures use it, according to my understanding.
Other than that, I don't think that the streets of joy and pleasure do more than intersect at a given place or two, but they are not the same and do not lead you to the same destination, except for those few intersections.

larsenb
Level 34 Illuminated
Posts: 10812
Location: Between here and Standing Rock

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by larsenb »

Rand wrote: November 17th, 2017, 11:00 am
larsenb wrote: November 15th, 2017, 11:36 pm
Rand wrote: November 15th, 2017, 2:56 pm . . . . . . Pleasure is, although enjoyable, a state of physical perception that can be noble, but can be distorted by the adversary to further his purposes. . . . . . .
Notice how you say: "Pleasure is . . . enjoyable . . . " Notice the embedded 'joy' in enjoyable. You could also say: "Joy is pleasurable" . . . and if you disagree with that statement, are you then saying that joy is not pleasurable, is not pleasing??

Of course you are welcome to select how you want to use the word pleasure. Philosophers do this type of thing quite a bit, but they try to make it very clear how they are expanding or narrowing the meaning of a word or phrase beyond or as a subset of the conventional meaning, and that the usage they put forth is to be used only in the context of their philosophical system.
Good observation. I would contend that, even though the root of enjoyable, is joy, it does not carry all of the meaning nor connotations of joy. I do have broader beliefs about the word Joy, and you could call them philosophical in context. I am looking at the word Joy as the scriptures use it, according to my understanding.
Other than that, I don't think that the streets of joy and pleasure do more than intersect at a given place or two, but they are not the same and do not lead you to the same destination, except for those few intersections.
Did you read my last post, above, where I mention what I think are the broader meanings and connotations of joy?

The intersection of joy and pleasure is precisely the point where you take pleasure in a real joyful experience. It's not anymore complicated than that, IMHO. Pleasure is simply your reaction to a whole variety of experiences, not just sexual and gustatory ones. These experiences include joy.

larsenb
Level 34 Illuminated
Posts: 10812
Location: Between here and Standing Rock

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by larsenb »

larsenb wrote: November 17th, 2017, 1:42 pm
Rand wrote: November 17th, 2017, 11:00 am
larsenb wrote: November 15th, 2017, 11:36 pm
Rand wrote: November 15th, 2017, 2:56 pm . . . . . . Pleasure is, although enjoyable, a state of physical perception that can be noble, but can be distorted by the adversary to further his purposes. . . . . . .
Notice how you say: "Pleasure is . . . enjoyable . . . " Notice the embedded 'joy' in enjoyable. You could also say: "Joy is pleasurable" . . . and if you disagree with that statement, are you then saying that joy is not pleasurable, is not pleasing??

Of course you are welcome to select how you want to use the word pleasure. Philosophers do this type of thing quite a bit, but they try to make it very clear how they are expanding or narrowing the meaning of a word or phrase beyond or as a subset of the conventional meaning, and that the usage they put forth is to be used only in the context of their philosophical system.
Good observation. I would contend that, even though the root of enjoyable, is joy, it does not carry all of the meaning nor connotations of joy. I do have broader beliefs about the word Joy, and you could call them philosophical in context. I am looking at the word Joy as the scriptures use it, according to my understanding.
Other than that, I don't think that the streets of joy and pleasure do more than intersect at a given place or two, but they are not the same and do not lead you to the same destination, except for those few intersections.
Did you read my last post, above, where I mention what I think are the broader meanings and connotations of joy?

The intersection of joy and pleasure is precisely the point where you take pleasure in a real joyful experience. It's not anymore complicated than that, IMHO. Pleasure is simply your reaction to a whole variety of experiences, not just sexual and gustatory ones. These experiences include joy.
You could almost say that pleasure is a reaction to an experience, and could thus, also be described as a secondary experience. It is an indication that you find an experience pleasing. Whereas, joy is a full-blown, primary experience. Pleasure in joy is just one of the secondary reaction experiences to the primary experience of joy. Pleasure is a description of one way you may react to a primary experience.

sushi_chef
captain of 1,000
Posts: 3693
Location: tokyo, jpn

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by sushi_chef »

pleasure might be sacrifice-able for the better cause, and then joy comes often after sacrificing some through trials of faith.
:arrow:

User avatar
BeNotDeceived
Agent38
Posts: 8960
Location: Tralfamadore
Contact:

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by BeNotDeceived »

Pleasure is physical

Joy is our goal.

brianj
captain of 1,000
Posts: 4066
Location: Vineyard, Utah

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by brianj »

BeNotDeceived wrote: November 19th, 2017, 5:53 am Pleasure is physical

Joy is our goal.
I'm going to disagree with your first point. I take great pleasure from reading a good book. Is that physical?

sushi_chef
captain of 1,000
Posts: 3693
Location: tokyo, jpn

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by sushi_chef »

physical pleasure can be joyable. for it says,

"15 And the voice spake unto him again the second time, What God hath cleansed, that call not thou common.

34 Then Peter opened his mouth, and said, Of a truth I perceive that God is no respecter of persons:

35 But in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted with him.
"
:arrow:

sushi_chef
captain of 1,000
Posts: 3693
Location: tokyo, jpn

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by sushi_chef »

also, says,

"15 Unto the pure all things are pure: but unto them that are defiled and unbelieving is nothing pure; but even their mind and conscience is defiled.
"
:arrow:

sushi_chef
captain of 1,000
Posts: 3693
Location: tokyo, jpn

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by sushi_chef »

and, of course, ideally speaking.
:arrow: :idea:

eddie
captain of 1,000
Posts: 2405

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by eddie »

I prefer the distinction between fun and happiness.
Fun is temporary, happiness is long lasting.

For example, my Mother went away from the Church, didn't need it anymore. She was rather wealthy and had fun buying new cars, Mercedes, escalades etc. After a drive or two the mundane set in, she then had to buy something else for fun. She never was happy without the gospel, it is everlasting happiness.

Rand
captain of 1,000
Posts: 2472

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by Rand »

If wickedness never was happiness, can the wicked not experience happiness? This is a trap question.

The distinction here is that there are states of being I will call emotions. Then there are states of being I would call virtues. Happiness can be both a virtue and an emotion. Is the state of emotional happiness the same as the state of the virtue of happiness? No. The wicked can not know the virtue of happiness while they are in the throes of wickedness.

The state of being the scriptures encourage is the state of virtue, not that of emotion. The difference being that virtue is a way of being, and emotion is a way of feeling. Virtue is the byproduct of righteous judgment and emotion is the by product of unrighteous judgment. Virtue is the result of the presence of the Holy Ghost. Emotion does not require the presence of the Holy Spirit. Virtue is a by product of the Grace of God, Emotions are a by product of the natural man. The initial question at the top of the thread is a trap question, because it does not distinguish between the two states of being: Emotion and Virtue. There is no good answer to a bad question. Because of the lack of specificity, it is a bad question.

In the same way, Pleasure can be an emotion, it could possibly be a virtue. I am not sure if it can be a virtue or not. Joy can be an emotion, and it is for sure a virtue. The two states are very different.

Emotions are a state of feeling based on the judgement of a situation or a circumstance. Virtue is a state of being that is godly in nature.

Juliet
captain of 1,000
Posts: 3701

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by Juliet »

Rand wrote: November 19th, 2017, 5:21 pm If wickedness never was happiness, can the wicked not experience happiness? This is a trap question.

The distinction here is that there are states of being I will call emotions. Then there are states of being I would call virtues. Happiness can be both a virtue and an emotion. Is the state of emotional happiness the same as the state of the virtue of happiness? No. The wicked can not know the virtue of happiness while they are in the throes of wickedness.

The state of being the scriptures encourage is the state of virtue, not that of emotion. The difference being that virtue is a way of being, and emotion is a way of feeling. Virtue is the byproduct of righteous judgment and emotion is the by product of unrighteous judgment. Virtue is the result of the presence of the Holy Ghost. Emotion does not require the presence of the Holy Spirit. Virtue is a by product of the Grace of God, Emotions are a by product of the natural man. The initial question at the top of the thread is a trap question, because it does not distinguish between the two states of being: Emotion and Virtue. There is no good answer to a bad question. Because of the lack of specificity, it is a bad question.

In the same way, Pleasure can be an emotion, it could possibly be a virtue. I am not sure if it can be a virtue or not. Joy can be an emotion, and it is for sure a virtue. The two states are very different.

Emotions are a state of feeling based on the judgement of a situation or a circumstance. Virtue is a state of being that is godly in nature.
So as we receive virtue, we have higher ways of comprehending all things, and pleasure or earthly things is properly balanced with love for all.

I think having the Holy Spirit is the ultimate gift that perhaps pleasure all too often is a compensation for, whereas for a virtuous person, pleasure is the outer manifestation of inward glory.

User avatar
skmo
captain of 1,000
Posts: 4495

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by skmo »

There are very few ways to find joy, they all require significant effort to achieve. There are lots of ways to find pleasure, not all of them lead to joy.

User avatar
BeNotDeceived
Agent38
Posts: 8960
Location: Tralfamadore
Contact:

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by BeNotDeceived »

brianj wrote: November 19th, 2017, 1:59 pm
BeNotDeceived wrote: November 19th, 2017, 5:53 am Pleasure is physical

Joy is our goal.
I'm going to disagree with your first point. I take great pleasure from reading a good book. Is that physical?
Men are that they might have joy, but this came about in connection with the fall. The pursuit of happiness is how it’s termed in the Declaration of Independence. Perhaps pleasure is experienced in the brain, whereas Joy is felt in the heart, mind and spirit? Pleasure may be carnal and bad, whereas joy is celestial and only good.

Reading righteousness script brings joy to those that seek after it.

What of bodiless Satan? Does he experience joy, pleasure or something else?

Juliet
captain of 1,000
Posts: 3701

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by Juliet »

BeNotDeceived wrote: November 20th, 2017, 3:10 am
brianj wrote: November 19th, 2017, 1:59 pm
BeNotDeceived wrote: November 19th, 2017, 5:53 am Pleasure is physical

Joy is our goal.
I'm going to disagree with your first point. I take great pleasure from reading a good book. Is that physical?
Men are that they might have joy, but this came about in connection with the fall. The pursuit of happiness is how it’s termed in the Declaration of Independence. Perhaps pleasure is experienced in the brain, whereas Joy is felt in the heart, mind and spirit? Pleasure may be carnal and bad, whereas joy is celestial and only good.

Reading righteousness script brings joy to those that seek after it.

What of bodiless Satan? Does he experience joy, pleasure or something else?
I was reading a study that showed that pedophiles usually have the reward centers malfunctioning, and so they act out because of the hormone dopamine. The hormone has no intersection in the brain with any type of emotional responce, hence, many feel guilty and sad about their actions.

This was a very important note for me, to see that reward response system in our brains is not connected with emotion. In order for us to find emotional joy, pleasure as a reward response in the brain has nothing to do with it.

However, pedophiles, with a non-functioning anti-reward dopamine circuitry are unable to control their urges very well and find themselves doing things to hurt others, which hurts them emotionally as well, but they are addicted to it.

So, I couldn't help but think, what if the solution is to TETHER our pleasure-response system with our emotions? SO, pleasure becomes something that is a reward when it is shared to create emotional well being for others? It isn't going to happen physiologically, it must have a spiritual start.

User avatar
skmo
captain of 1,000
Posts: 4495

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by skmo »

brianj wrote: November 19th, 2017, 1:59 pm
BeNotDeceived wrote: November 19th, 2017, 5:53 am Pleasure is physical

Joy is our goal.
I'm going to disagree with your first point. I take great pleasure from reading a good book. Is that physical?
In most cases, yes, it is. You read a book for a number of reasons, but if one of them is reading for pleasure, you're at least partially releasing the same feel good chemicals one gets from sex or drugs. That doesn't mean you're not capable of deriving substantive meaning from acquiring new knowledge, but "...great pleasure from reading..." is something one hears much more often from women, and their pleasure centers usually have
more complex wiring than men (face it - we're simple creatures) and I don't doubt your statement, but I've known many women who derive physical pleasure from reading.

That's not to intimate any kind of eroticism into your reading, but the pleasure aspect of it is still usually a physical thing.

larsenb
Level 34 Illuminated
Posts: 10812
Location: Between here and Standing Rock

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by larsenb »

skmo wrote: November 20th, 2017, 11:50 am
brianj wrote: November 19th, 2017, 1:59 pm
BeNotDeceived wrote: November 19th, 2017, 5:53 am Pleasure is physical

Joy is our goal.
I'm going to disagree with your first point. I take great pleasure from reading a good book. Is that physical?
In most cases, yes, it is. You read a book for a number of reasons, but if one of them is reading for pleasure, you're at least partially releasing the same feel good chemicals one gets from sex or drugs. That doesn't mean you're not capable of deriving substantive meaning from acquiring new knowledge, but "...great pleasure from reading..." is something one hears much more often from women, and their pleasure centers usually have
more complex wiring than men (face it - we're simple creatures) and I don't doubt your statement, but I've known many women who derive physical pleasure from reading.

That's not to intimate any kind of eroticism into your reading, but the pleasure aspect of it is still usually a physical thing.
I still contend that what you find pleasing could be said to give you pleasure . . . same root. You find many things pleasing in life. Strictly tying 'pleasure' to physical pleasure is too either-or, in my view.

brianj
captain of 1,000
Posts: 4066
Location: Vineyard, Utah

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by brianj »

skmo wrote: November 20th, 2017, 11:50 am
brianj wrote: November 19th, 2017, 1:59 pm
BeNotDeceived wrote: November 19th, 2017, 5:53 am Pleasure is physical

Joy is our goal.
I'm going to disagree with your first point. I take great pleasure from reading a good book. Is that physical?
In most cases, yes, it is. You read a book for a number of reasons, but if one of them is reading for pleasure, you're at least partially releasing the same feel good chemicals one gets from sex or drugs. That doesn't mean you're not capable of deriving substantive meaning from acquiring new knowledge, but "...great pleasure from reading..." is something one hears much more often from women, and their pleasure centers usually have
more complex wiring than men (face it - we're simple creatures) and I don't doubt your statement, but I've known many women who derive physical pleasure from reading.

That's not to intimate any kind of eroticism into your reading, but the pleasure aspect of it is still usually a physical thing.
Try this: sit down, close your eyes, and spend a few minutes remembering and visualizing a very exciting and pleasurable experience in your life. Do you feel pleasure even in the absence of physical stimulus?

Right now I am reading Unsinkable by Abby Sunderland. Some of her first words are: "As a sailor, you dream of seeing waves like that, rolling mountains of water that look like they're covered in dark gray silk." In the first chapter of Moby Dick, Ishmael finishes the first paragraph by saying: "If they but knew it, almost all men in their degree, some time or other, cherish very nearly the same feelings towards the ocean with me."

I derive great pleasure from stories like these, stories of people having adventures on the high seas that I dream of. And there's nothing erotic about these stories. Someone who can get turned on by a guy surviving his ship sinking by floating on a friend's coffin, or a 16 year old girl trying to sail around the world solo and nonstop, is a pretty sick person.

User avatar
skmo
captain of 1,000
Posts: 4495

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by skmo »

brianj wrote: November 20th, 2017, 10:18 pm Try this: sit down, close your eyes, and spend a few minutes remembering and visualizing a very exciting and pleasurable experience in your life. Do you feel pleasure even in the absence of physical stimulus?
Yes, I do. The pleasure comes from my brain remembering something pleasurable and releasing a chemical, dopamine, that helps me re-experience the pleasure. This is processed by the nucleus accumbens shell, the pleasure center of the brain. An artificial stimulant, like an opioid or a cannabinoid, creates an even stronger reaction, which explains why drugs are so easy to get addicted to, but whether it's natural or artificial, pleasure is a result of a physical change felt by the brain.

Benjamin_LK
captain of 1,000
Posts: 2502
Location: Valley Forge, Pennsylvania
Contact:

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by Benjamin_LK »

In my experience, no they are not the same.

User avatar
BeNotDeceived
Agent38
Posts: 8960
Location: Tralfamadore
Contact:

Re: Is Pleasure same as Joy?

Post by BeNotDeceived »


Happiness same as joy :?:

Post Reply