It doesn't matter that he was absent. He was out doing missionary work. Oliver Cowdery fulfilled the assignment Joseph gave him. The point is that things were done in an orderly and public fashion. No deeds were done in the dark, like in 1921, or 1981.Arenera wrote: ↑July 19th, 2017, 1:25 pmJoseph Smith wasn't at the vote, neither were the 12 apostles. You are just making things up.underdog wrote: ↑July 19th, 2017, 1:08 pmHello Br Lenox!brlenox wrote: ↑July 18th, 2017, 10:26 pmDog, you seem very concerned about the Lectures on faith and the fact that you perceive them to be scriptural canon as they were voted on by the membership and accepted into the canon. There is a little known factoid that I wonder if you have done any research on. Would you provide evidence that the Book of Mormon was presented to the church and voted on to be included in the official cannon.underdog wrote: ↑July 18th, 2017, 8:45 pm I don't blame you for resisting what I'm saying. Again, the reason you resist is because of what you PRESUME to be true. Your sacred cow is "the Brethren can't lead us astray," or that "the Brethren are true messengers." The list of the acts of apostasy of the Brethren utterly destroy that sacred cow. You must choose to hold onto the cow, at your eternal peril, or send it out to pasture.
If you find the evidence concerning such, and I suspect you will not, then if you would find the vote on when the Bible was accepted into church canon.
Thank you,
I do believe the LoF are scripture. What qualifies something as scripture? DC 68:4 says:
I don't see a vote as being a required element to be scripture. The DC 68:4 definition of course opens up everything anybody has ever said to being scripture. Mormon abridged the records he had into one book, or the unsealed portion which was translated. There's much more "out there". The record of his abridgment, as far as I understand was never voted on. Neither were other books of Scriptures, like the Bible, that I'm aware of. I'm not 100% sure.And whatsoever they shall speak when moved upon by the Holy Ghost shall be scripture, shall be the will of the Lord, shall be the mind of the Lord, shall be the word of the Lord, shall be the voice of the Lord, and the power of God unto salvation.
But we do know the Lectures of Faith, as the doctrine part of the Doctrines and Covenants, were voted on.
But the BoM was not voted on and def was not received by covenant. One of the ways to remove the Lord's condemnation is to receive the BoM as a covenant. DC 84:57 says:
Interestingly, receiving the BoM as a covenant will happen this very year - Sept 2017.And they shall remain under this condemnation until they repent and remember the new covenant, even the Book of Mormon and the former commandments which I have given them, not only to say, but to do according to that which I have written—
To your questions, I don't know for sure. Can you enlighten me? I'm guessing the BoM and Bible were never voted on. What is the factoid you reference? My "concern" is that Joseph's say on the matter -- that the LoF WERE the leading items of the doctrine of the Restoration -- was overruled or usurped by apostles in 1921. They did this in a most NON transparent way. They removed them. No discussion. No vote. At least Joseph was public about it. He knew that accepting these into our canon was a big deal, thus arranging an official meeting in which there was in fact a vote, which was unanimous.
Thank you,
Underdog
Though the assembly was convened by the Presidency of the Church, several of them were absent at the time of the vote. So the responsibility of presenting the book to the conference fell to Oliver Cowdery, a member of both the presidency and the four man publication committee and Assistant President of the Church at the moment that this took place. Sidney Rigdon, the other presidency member and committee member, stood and explained the matter by which they intended to obtain the voice of the assembly for or against said book. Voting on the book proceeded by quorums and groups with the leader of each group bearing witness of the truth of the volume before his group voted. And then they proceeded to vote. And they voted by quorums from the least to the greatest. Then after all the quorums of the church had accepted the Doctrine and Covenants, the first 70 some pages of which were The Lectures on Faith, the General Assembly voted, including everyone who was present. Children, women, everyone voted. They all sustained this as the Doctrine of the Church.
Nothing has been made up. I'm dealing in facts of history.